Activity: Comparing and Contrasting the Treatment of Ukrainian Refugees and Refugees from Africa or the Middle East
Objective: To explore and analyze the disparities in the treatment of European migrants (specifically Ukrainian refugees) and non-European migrants (refugees from Africa or the Middle East) by examining various aspects such as media portrayal, public perception, government policies, and humanitarian aid.
Materials: 1. Internet access or printed articles/news reports on the treatment of Ukrainian refugees and refugees from Africa or the Middle East. 2. Paper and pens for note-taking and brainstorming.
Instructions:
-
Introduction (10 minutes): a. Begin the activity by discussing the concept of refugees and the challenges they face when seeking asylum in different countries. b. Explain that the activity will focus on comparing and contrasting the treatment of Ukrainian refugees and refugees from Africa or the Middle East, specifically highlighting the disparities between European migrants and non-European migrants.
-
Research (15 minutes): a. Divide the students into small groups (3-4 students per group). b. Assign each group either Ukrainian refugees or refugees from Africa or the Middle East. c. Instruct the groups to research and gather information on the treatment of their assigned group, considering aspects such as media portrayal, public perception, government policies, and humanitarian aid. d. Encourage students to use reliable sources and take notes on their findings.
-
Group Discussion (20 minutes): a. Bring the groups back together and facilitate a discussion where each group presents their findings. b. Encourage students to share specific examples, statistics, or anecdotes to support their points. c. Prompt the students to identify and discuss any disparities they notice between the treatment of European migrants and non-European migrants.
-
Reflection and Analysis (15 minutes): a. Lead a class discussion on the disparities identified during the group presentations. b. Encourage students to reflect on the reasons behind these disparities, considering factors such as historical context, cultural biases, geopolitical influences, and media representation. c. Discuss the potential consequences of these disparities on the lives and well-being of refugees.
-
Personal Reflection (10 minutes): a. Ask each student to individually reflect on what they have learned from this activity. b. Prompt them to consider their own biases and assumptions about refugees and how this activity has challenged or reinforced their perspectives. c. Encourage students to share their reflections with the class, fostering an open and respectful discussion.
-
Conclusion (5 minutes): Summarize the key points discussed during the activity and emphasize the importance of empathy, understanding, and fair treatment for all refugees, regardless of their country of origin.
Note: It is crucial to approach this activity with sensitivity and respect for all students involved. Encourage open dialogue while ensuring a safe and inclusive environment for everyone.
Loading...